| Home |

I haven't touched on AI yet, but I think it's about time I did, mainly to address it's increasing use in online arguments about quality and ratings. The very first thing to consider is that since 2005 Doctor Who has had very good AI. Generally an AI of over 85 is considered Excellent, while over 90 is considered Exceptional. 60 or less is Poor, while 55 or less is Very Poor. Anything between 75 and 65 is considered Good.
The graph above is of the average for each series. This figure is derived from averaging the AI score for each individual story, the BARB panel doesn't score at a Series or Season level. So this is a very rough guide of how things are, and the devil is definitely in the details. For example, Series 1's AI scores ranged from 76 to 89, with the first two stories of Series 1 both recieving an Appreciation Index of 76, while every other story achieved 80 or above. Only three stories hit 85 or above - "The Doctor Dances", "Bad Wolf", and "The Parting of the Ways".
By the time of Series 2 the AI is consistently between 83 and 86, peaking once at 89 ("Doomsday") and hitting 76 once ("Love and Monsters").
The AI for Series 3 never drops below 84, and peaks at 88 twice. The AI for Series 4 never drops below 86 and on two occasions peaks at 91. So that's an Excellent set of stories, with two Exceptional ones.
Doctor Who's year of Specials (2009) sees the AI between 87 and 89, while Matt Smith's first series garners scores of between 84 and 89 (with most above 85). Series 6 is much the same, with two stories hitting the 88 mark, one hitting 83, and the rest 85 or above. Series 7 completes the trilogy, with one story hitting 89, three stories 88, five 84, and the rest 85 and above.
Now we've seen Series 8, 9 and 10, and Fandom would have you believe the Sky is Falling. For the first time since 2005, Doctor Who episodes have been getting Audience Appreciation figures of 82 (and the odd 80). Now although Series 8 appears to be appreciated less when compared to the series before it, 82 to 84 are still considered Good scores, and Series 8 has received two 85s ("Mummy on the Orient Express" and "Flatline"). Series 9 appears to be appreciated much the same (although there is a glaring "78" in there, for the experimental - and frankly not well-received - "Sleep No More"), as does Series 10. It is tempting to attribute this to the "acquired taste" of Peter Capaldi's 12th Doctor, who (although critically praised) perhaps oesn't cut it as much as Matt Smith and David Tennant did with the under-12's.
We'll see what happens after the 2017 Christmas Special. New Doctor, new appreciation?
-Spacewarp July 2017
| Home |